June 2016

# 4 = 5; where's the catch?

My friend (the one who had tried to prove that 1 = 2 was at it again; this time he was bent upon convincing me that 4 = 5!

"Hey, I can prove that 4 = 5," he said. I was reading a very interesting story book, and I wanted him to go away. But you have to be civil; you can't tell your friends to go away, especially those friends who lend you story books. The story book I was reading had, in fact, been borrowed from him.

I suppressed a sigh, and trying to appear curious I asked him to show me how four could equal five.

The friend always carried a notebook and pen with him; even on the playground! He whipped out the notebook and wrote:

-20 = -20

"Of course," I said. "Even a kid knows that 1 = 1, 5 = 5, 10000 = 10000, -20 = -20."

"But I can write -20 as 16 - 36; again, -20 is also 25 - 45."

"Sure," I said. "We all know that 16 - 36 = -20, and 25 - 45 = -20."

"So, instead of writing -20 = -20, I can write 16 - 36 = 25 - 45," he said looking at me.

I saw nothing wrong in that.

But 16 = 42, 36 = 4 x 9, 25 = 52 and 45 = 5 x 9, he went on.

I knew that much.

Therefore, 42 - 4 x 9 = 52 - 5 x 9.

That was alright with me. I had no objections.

"Allow me to add 81/4 to both sides; since I am adding 81/4 to both sides the equality holds," he said.

I gave him my permission.

So, now we have 42 - 4 x 9 + 81/4 = 52 - 5 x 9 + 81/4.

I nodded my head sagely in agreement.

So, (4 - 9/2)2 = (5 - 9/2)2.

That stumped me for a while; but, then, I remembered that a2 - 2ab + b2 = (a - b)2. So, LHS = (4 - 9/2)2 = 42 - 2x4x9/2 + (9/2)2 = 42 - 4 x 9 + 81/4. Similarly, the RHS was 52 - 5 x 9 + 81/4. Everything was fine.

Since (4 - 9/2)2 = (5 - 9/2)2, this means on taking the square roots (4 - 9/2) = (5 - 9/2), he said looking me straight into the eyes.

We can cancel out -9/2 from both sides; so what we have is 4 = 5. There, I have proved that 4 = 5; anything wrong in the proof? he asked me grinning from ear to ear.

• Union Public Service Commission - www.upsc.gov.in
• IIT-Kharagpur - www.iitkgp.ac.in
• Indian Statistical Institute - www.isical.ac.in
• Indian Institute of Technology Madras - www.iitm.ac.in
• Indian Institute of Management, Ahmedabad - www.iimahd.ernet.in
• Indian Institute of Mass Commission - www.iimc.nic.in
• IIT Bombay - www.iitb.ac.in
• Birla Institute of Technology, Ranchi - www.bitmesra.ac.in
• Central Institute of Fisheries Nautical and Engineering Training - www.cifnet.nic.in
• Indian Institute of Information Technology, Allahabad (Deemed University) - www.iiita.ac.in
• Central Marine Fisheries Research Institute, Kochi - www.cmfri.com
• Tata Institute of Social Sciences, Mumbai - www.tiss.edu

DISCLAIMER: The contents of this website are for informational purposes only. Although due care is taken, the correctness and accuracy cannot be guaranteed. The science and medical research articles are for informational purposes only, aimed at kindling an interest in science. They are not intended to provide any kind of advice.